By Steven Loader, PhD, CMHC
A Sound Mind Counseling | Utah
In On Combat: The Psychology and Physiology of Deadly Conflict in War and in Peace, retired Lieutenant Colonel Dave Grossman and coauthor Loren Christensen (2004) discuss an analogy that divides people into three symbolic categories: sheep, wolves, and sheepdogs. Within this metaphor, sheep represent generally peaceful individuals, wolves symbolize those willing to exploit or harm others, and sheepdogs represent individuals prepared to confront danger in defense of others. Although memorable, the analogy raises an important psychological question:
What happens when someone who identifies as a protector begins to exhibit behaviors resembling those of an aggressor?
The distinction between protection and aggression becomes particularly important when examining the relationship between authority, personal identity, and interpersonal control. Individuals entrusted with responsibility for others may occasionally encounter situations in which maintaining order becomes difficult to distinguish from maintaining personal control. Disagreement may be interpreted as disrespect, challenges to authority may be experienced as personal threats, and the enforcement of expectations may gradually become intertwined with the preservation of status or self-image. Under certain circumstances, behaviors initially justified as protective or corrective may become increasingly coercive, intimidating, or punitive.
These dynamics are not limited to military or law enforcement environments. Similar patterns may emerge within families, workplaces, educational institutions, organizations, and intimate relationships. A parent, for example, may believe that restricting a child's independence is necessary for safety, even when those restrictions exceed reasonable developmental needs. A supervisor may characterize intimidation as discipline, while an organizational leader may justify humiliation or excessive control as necessary for maintaining standards. In each example, the individual's stated intention may be protective or corrective, yet the consequences of their behavior may undermine the autonomy, dignity, or psychological well-being of others.
Importantly, the exercise of authority, establishment of firm boundaries, and enforcement of legitimate expectations should not automatically be interpreted as abusive. Effective leadership and responsible caregiving frequently require difficult decisions, accountability, and the management of interpersonal conflict. The psychological concern arises when the exercise of authority becomes disproportionately focused on protecting the authority figure's personal status, emotional security, or perceived entitlement to control rather than fulfilling legitimate responsibilities.
Research examining power, threatened self-image, narcissistic traits, psychological entitlement, moral disengagement, and leadership provides several theoretical and empirical perspectives through which these dynamics can be understood. These areas of research suggest that authority and perceived threats to self-image may, under certain conditions, interact with individual characteristics and situational influences in ways that increase the likelihood of defensive, controlling, or aggressive behavior. However, these processes are neither inevitable nor universal, and no single psychological characteristic adequately explains abusive uses of authority.
The sheepdog analogy should therefore be understood as an illustrative metaphor rather than a scientifically validated classification of personality or behavior. Existing research does not establish that individuals who identify as protectors are inherently more likely to become abusive, nor does it demonstrate a predictable progression from protective identity to aggression. Instead, psychological research offers a framework for examining how power, ego, perceived threats, and moral justification may intersect, helping distinguish authority exercised in service of others from authority increasingly exercised to preserve personal control.
Protection and control are not the same. Legitimate authority establishes reasonable boundaries, while coercive control may involve intimidation, disproportionate restrictions, or retaliation.
Threatened self-image can contribute to defensive aggression. Research suggests that perceived challenges to self-worth may influence aggressive responses under certain conditions.
Power can influence judgment. Some experimental research links experiences of power with overconfidence, making accountability and corrective feedback important.
Empathy and authority can coexist. Maintaining appropriate limits does not require dismissing another person's perspective or dignity.
Harmful behavior may be morally justified. People sometimes explain harmful actions as necessary, protective, or deserved.
Accountability matters. Authority is more difficult to evaluate when the person exercising it also controls whether their conduct can be questioned.
These findings describe psychological possibilities and research-supported associations, not a universal pathway from leadership or protective identity to abuse.
Authority serves an important function in families, workplaces, educational institutions, and organizations by establishing structure, maintaining expectations, and promoting safety and stability. Parents establish boundaries for their children, teachers manage classroom environments, supervisors make organizational decisions, and leaders assume responsibility for those entrusted to their care. Although these responsibilities are legitimate and often necessary, psychological difficulties may emerge when an individual's sense of personal worth becomes increasingly dependent on being obeyed, admired, or perceived as unquestionably competent. Under these circumstances, challenges to authority may be experienced not simply as disagreements about decisions or procedures but as threats to personal identity and self-esteem.
Consider a supervisor who believes that effective leadership requires employees to follow instructions without question. When an employee raises a reasonable concern about a decision, the supervisor may interpret the disagreement as a challenge to personal competence rather than an opportunity to evaluate an alternative perspective. What might otherwise be a routine workplace discussion can acquire a more threatening emotional meaning, particularly if the supervisor equates disagreement with disrespect or diminished authority. Consequently, the interaction may shift away from collaborative problem-solving and toward defending personal status. Although this example does not necessarily indicate abusive behavior, it illustrates how authority can become intertwined with self-image and how ordinary disagreements may escalate when perceived as personal threats.
Research on threatened egotism provides one theoretical perspective for understanding these reactions. Baumeister et al. (1996) challenged the assumption that aggression primarily results from low self-esteem, proposing instead that aggressive responses may sometimes emerge when favorable self-perceptions encounter threatening feedback. Building on this perspective, Bushman and Baumeister (1998) experimentally examined relationships among narcissism, self-esteem, ego threats, and aggression. Their findings associated narcissism and insulting feedback with aggressive responses under laboratory conditions, suggesting that threatened self-image may contribute to certain forms of defensive aggression. A subsequent synthesis by Baumeister et al. (2000) further distinguished narcissism and threatened egotism from low self-esteem as explanations for aggression. However, these findings should not be interpreted as evidence that criticism inevitably produces violence, that narcissistic individuals necessarily become abusive, or that laboratory measures of aggression are equivalent to sustained coercive behavior in everyday relationships.
The implications of defensive responses may become particularly important when individuals occupy positions of authority. Unlike an ordinary interpersonal disagreement, conflict involving an authority figure may occur within a relationship characterized by unequal access to resources, decision-making power, or opportunities for accountability. A supervisor may influence employment conditions, a parent may determine access to privileges and resources, and an organizational leader may shape whether disagreement is welcomed or punished. Consequently, the central psychological concern is not merely whether an individual experiences criticism as threatening, but how that individual responds when their position provides opportunities to act on those feelings. Responsible authority requires recognizing the distinction between defending legitimate responsibilities and defending one's personal sense of importance.
Power influences not only what individuals are able to do but potentially how they perceive opportunities, evaluate risks, and assess their own judgments. Keltner et al. (2003) proposed an approach-inhibition theory of power, suggesting that experiences of greater power may increase attention to rewards, opportunities, and goal-directed behavior, whereas reduced power may heighten sensitivity to threats, constraints, and potential consequences. This theoretical framework offers a way to understand how authority may influence psychological processes, although it does not establish that possessing power inevitably produces aggression, unethical behavior, or disregard for others.
Experimental research has also examined the relationship between power and overconfidence. Fast et al. (2012) investigated whether experiences of power could influence confidence in personal judgment, reporting findings suggesting that power may increase confidence beyond what decision-making accuracy warrants under certain experimental conditions. Although the researchers acknowledged limitations involving sample characteristics and the broader applicability of their findings, the study raises an important consideration for leadership: confidence and accuracy are not necessarily equivalent. Individuals may feel increasingly certain about their decisions without a corresponding improvement in the quality of those decisions.
Confidence is often essential for effective leadership, particularly when individuals must make difficult decisions, assume responsibility, or act under uncertain circumstances. However, confidence can become problematic when it reduces openness to corrective information or alternative perspectives. A leader who assumes that their judgment is consistently superior may become less willing to consider reasonable objections, while an authority figure who rarely receives honest feedback may begin to interpret silence as agreement. In these situations, the absence of disagreement does not necessarily indicate that decisions are appropriate or that others feel respected. It may instead reflect an environment in which individuals perceive little opportunity to challenge authority.
Overconfidence alone does not constitute abusive behavior, nor does decisive leadership necessarily indicate arrogance or psychological dysfunction. Nevertheless, research on power and judgment highlights the importance of feedback, consultation, and meaningful accountability. Responsible authority involves more than the ability to make decisions; it also requires the willingness to evaluate those decisions critically, acknowledge mistakes, and recognize that holding a position of power does not guarantee the accuracy of one's judgment.
The concept of control appears frequently in discussions of leadership, interpersonal relationships, and psychological functioning, yet the term encompasses several distinct processes that should not be confused. Self-regulation refers to an individual's ability to manage emotions, impulses, and behavior, particularly when navigating challenging circumstances. Remaining composed during disagreement, tolerating frustration, and responding thoughtfully rather than impulsively are examples of psychological self-control. Legitimate authority, by comparison, involves establishing and enforcing appropriate expectations, responsibilities, and boundaries within a particular role. A teacher addressing disruptive classroom behavior or a supervisor responding to employee misconduct may be exercising necessary authority rather than attempting to dominate another person. Excessive or coercive interpersonal control differs from both processes because it involves restricting another person's autonomy through disproportionate demands, intimidation, threats, manipulation, or retaliation.
Distinguishing among these forms of control is essential because organization, decisiveness, and appropriate boundary-setting do not inherently indicate controlling or authoritarian behavior. Similarly, coercive conduct does not require a formal leadership position and may occur within intimate relationships, families, friendships, or other interpersonal settings. The distinction often becomes clearer when considering the purpose, proportionality, and consequences of a person's actions. Restrictions connected to legitimate responsibilities, applied consistently, and open to reasonable evaluation differ meaningfully from demands for unquestioning obedience. When authority becomes increasingly concerned with securing compliance rather than addressing an identifiable responsibility, the relationship between protection and control warrants closer examination.
Understanding excessive control also requires caution when interpreting motivation. Some individuals may struggle to tolerate uncertainty, whereas others may hold rigid beliefs about authority, perceive disagreement as threatening to their status, experience a sense of entitlement, or deliberately exploit interpersonal power. These explanations are not interchangeable, and a preference for control does not independently establish narcissism, insecurity, or any psychological diagnosis. Because internal motives cannot always be reliably inferred from outward behavior, a more useful approach is to examine what the individual actually does, how those actions affect others, whether restrictions are proportionate to legitimate concerns, and whether meaningful accountability remains possible.
Discussions of problematic authority frequently involve concepts such as confidence, arrogance, narcissism, and entitlement. Although these characteristics may overlap in certain circumstances, they represent different psychological constructs and should not be treated as equivalent. Confidence generally involves believing in one's abilities and may coexist with humility, flexibility, and openness to corrective feedback. Arrogance, in contrast, may involve exaggerated self-evaluation or a sense of superiority over others. Narcissistic traits encompass a range of characteristics that may include grandiosity, vulnerability, sensitivity to evaluation, and interpersonal difficulties, with substantial variation among individuals. Psychological entitlement refers more specifically to expectations of preferential treatment, special consideration, or advantages that may not be justified by the circumstances.
Research has explored relationships among these characteristics and how individuals interpret fairness, criticism, and interpersonal expectations. Queiri and Alhejji (2025), for example, examined narcissism, psychological entitlement, and perceived inequity among 150 employees in Oman. Their cross-sectional findings suggested associations among these constructs, including a role for entitlement in the relationship between narcissism and perceived inequity. However, because the study relied on self-report measures and a cross-sectional design, its findings cannot establish causal relationships or demonstrate that narcissism and entitlement inevitably produce abusive behavior. Instead, the research offers a perspective on how certain personality characteristics may be associated with interpretations of fairness and perceived treatment by others.
These distinctions become particularly relevant when examining authority relationships in which expectations and accountability may be applied unevenly. A leader may interpret reasonable oversight as unfair interference, a supervisor may believe organizational standards should apply to employees but not management, or a parent may experience a child's developmentally appropriate independence as personal disloyalty. Such examples illustrate how perceptions of entitlement or threatened authority might contribute to interpersonal conflict, but they do not provide sufficient evidence for diagnosing narcissism or attributing a particular psychological motive. Abusive behavior can occur in the absence of narcissistic traits, just as individuals displaying narcissistic characteristics do not necessarily engage in abusive conduct. Psychological concepts are therefore most useful when they contribute to understanding patterns of behavior, interpersonal consequences, and potential mechanisms rather than serving as labels that substitute for careful evaluation.
Healthy boundaries are an essential component of responsible authority and effective interpersonal relationships. They clarify expectations, establish responsibilities, and communicate the consequences of behavior while helping preserve safety, dignity, and appropriate independence. A boundary does not become problematic simply because another person disagrees with it or experiences frustration when it is enforced. Difficulties may arise, however, when an interaction shifts away from addressing a legitimate concern and becomes increasingly focused on determining who will prevail. In these circumstances, enforcing an expectation may become entangled with defending personal authority, and an otherwise manageable disagreement may escalate into a struggle over obedience, status, or control.
Educational research provides a useful illustration of how authority conflicts can develop and how they may be approached differently. Razer (2021) examined efforts to move from escalating power struggles toward benevolent authority and empathic limit-setting within educational practice. The research explored how teachers could maintain appropriate behavioral expectations while reconsidering their interpretations of student resistance and examining their own responses to conflict. Although this action research was conducted within an educational context and should not be interpreted as experimental proof that empathy prevents abusive leadership across settings, it illustrates an important distinction between maintaining legitimate authority and escalating interpersonal conflict through increasingly adversarial responses.
The broader relevance of this distinction extends beyond classrooms. A teacher may maintain expectations without humiliating a student, a supervisor may address performance concerns without interpreting disagreement as a personal challenge, and an individual in a close relationship may communicate legitimate needs without attempting to control another person's independent thoughts or choices. In each situation, the exercise of authority or establishment of boundaries can remain consistent with respect for the other person's dignity and autonomy. The central issue is whether the behavior serves a reasonable and proportionate purpose or whether securing submission has become an objective in itself. The ability to enforce a boundary is fundamentally different from the perceived need to make another person submit in order to preserve one's sense of authority or security.
Healthy boundaries are an essential component of responsible authority and effective interpersonal relationships. They clarify expectations, establish responsibilities, and communicate the consequences of behavior while helping preserve safety, dignity, and appropriate independence. A boundary does not become problematic simply because another person disagrees with it or experiences frustration when it is enforced. Difficulties may arise, however, when an interaction shifts away from addressing a legitimate concern and becomes increasingly focused on determining who will prevail. In these circumstances, enforcing an expectation may become entangled with defending personal authority, and an otherwise manageable disagreement may escalate into a struggle over obedience, status, or control.
Educational research provides a useful illustration of how authority conflicts can develop and how they may be approached differently. Razer (2021) examined efforts to move from escalating power struggles toward benevolent authority and empathic limit-setting within educational practice. The research explored how teachers could maintain appropriate behavioral expectations while reconsidering their interpretations of student resistance and examining their own responses to conflict. Although this action research was conducted within an educational context and should not be interpreted as experimental proof that empathy prevents abusive leadership across settings, it illustrates an important distinction between maintaining legitimate authority and escalating interpersonal conflict through increasingly adversarial responses.
The broader relevance of this distinction extends beyond classrooms. A teacher may maintain expectations without humiliating a student, a supervisor may address performance concerns without interpreting disagreement as a personal challenge, and an individual in a close relationship may communicate legitimate needs without attempting to control another person's independent thoughts or choices. In each situation, the exercise of authority or establishment of boundaries can remain consistent with respect for the other person's dignity and autonomy. The central issue is whether the behavior serves a reasonable and proportionate purpose or whether securing submission has become an objective in itself. The ability to enforce a boundary is fundamentally different from the perceived need to make another person submit to preserve one's sense of authority or security.
One of the more complicated aspects of human behavior is that individuals may sincerely believe they are acting responsibly, ethically, or protectively while engaging in conduct that causes harm. Albert Bandura's research on moral disengagement provides a psychological framework for understanding how people may justify actions that would otherwise conflict with their moral standards. Moral disengagement involves cognitive processes through which harmful conduct may be portrayed as serving a greater good, its consequences minimized, responsibility displaced or diffused, or blame directed toward those who experience the harm (Bandura, 1999). These processes help explain how individuals may maintain a favorable view of themselves while engaging in behavior that would ordinarily invite moral scrutiny.
Within relationships involving authority, moral justification may appear through explanations emphasizing discipline, protection, loyalty, or necessity. A supervisor who publicly humiliates an employee may describe the behavior as essential for improving performance, while a parent who imposes excessive restrictions may believe that such measures are necessary to prevent harm. Similarly, an organizational leader may interpret the suppression of disagreement as a reasonable sacrifice for maintaining stability. Statements such as "I am doing this for their own good," "They need to learn respect," or "I had no choice" may reflect genuine beliefs, but their sincerity does not independently establish that the underlying behavior is appropriate. Context remains essential because some difficult decisions involve legitimate competing responsibilities, and the language of protection or necessity is not inherently evidence of wrongdoing.
The psychological concern emerges when moral explanations begin to replace meaningful consideration of proportionality, consequences, available alternatives, and personal responsibility. Importantly, harmful conduct does not necessarily mean that an individual is consciously deceiving others about their intentions. Self-serving interpretations, rigid beliefs, deliberate manipulation, and genuine misunderstanding may sometimes produce similar outward explanations, even when the underlying psychological processes differ. Consequently, evaluating problematic authority requires attention not only to stated intentions but also to observable behavior, its effects on others, and the individual's willingness to reconsider actions when confronted with credible feedback. A person may continue to understand their conduct as protective even when others experience intimidation, humiliation, or unnecessary restrictions. The protective explanation therefore warrants careful examination rather than automatic acceptance or dismissal.
Empathy is an important consideration in understanding how individuals exercise authority and respond to the needs of others. Broadly, empathy involves recognizing, understanding, or responding to another person's emotional experience, although these processes may involve distinct cognitive and emotional components. Empathy does not require agreement with every request, avoidance of difficult decisions, or abandonment of appropriate boundaries. Rather, it can contribute to the ability to consider how decisions affect other people, particularly when relationships involve unequal power, competing needs, or the potential for interpersonal harm.
Research has examined whether experiences of power influence empathy-related processes and attitudes associated with aggression. Guo and Yun (2026) conducted two experiments investigating experimentally induced power, empathy, and implicit attitudes toward violence. In their first experiment, state empathy partially mediated the relationship between power priming and implicit attitudes toward violence, while their second experiment identified a moderating role for trait empathy, with relationships differing according to levels of empathy. These findings suggest that empathy may be relevant to understanding how experiences of power relate to automatic evaluations of violence. However, the researchers examined implicit attitudes rather than actual aggressive or abusive behavior, and their brief experimental manipulations cannot fully reproduce the complexity of sustained authority within families, workplaces, or organizations. The findings therefore do not establish that powerful individuals become violent because they lose empathy, but they provide a basis for continued investigation of the relationship between power and empathic functioning.
Within everyday authority relationships, empathy may help individuals balance necessary expectations with consideration for the experiences and autonomy of others. A supervisor can address performance concerns while acknowledging an employee's perspective, just as a parent can maintain appropriate safety expectations while respecting a child's developmental need for increasing independence. Such responses do not require surrendering responsibility or allowing others to disregard legitimate boundaries. Instead, they illustrate how authority and empathy can coexist, with each serving a different but potentially complementary function. Responsible authority may therefore involve both the willingness to establish appropriate limits and the capacity to recognize how those limits are experienced by the people affected.
Toxic Leadership and Organizational Culture
Although harmful leadership is frequently attributed to individual personality characteristics, authority is exercised within broader social, organizational, and institutional environments. These environments influence which behaviors are rewarded, which practices become normalized, and whether individuals feel able to question decisions without fear of retaliation. Consequently, understanding problematic authority requires consideration not only of the characteristics and motivations of individual leaders but also of the structures, expectations, and incentives that may enable harmful conduct or discourage meaningful accountability.
Research examining toxic leadership offers an important perspective on how organizational environments may contribute to harmful uses of authority. In a scoping review of 26 studies involving high-performance sports, Lundqvist et al. (2026) identified a range of leadership behaviors described as toxic or destructive, including intimidation, manipulation, and emotionally abusive coaching practices. The reviewed literature described adverse outcomes involving athletes’ psychological well-being, motivation, performance, and continued participation in sport. The authors also identified organizational and cultural conditions, including unequal power relationships, performance-oriented expectations, and limited accountability, as factors that may help maintain harmful leadership practices. Importantly, the review highlighted substantial variation in how toxic leadership was defined and studied, limiting the strength and generalizability of its conclusions. Although these findings arise from high-performance sports rather than clinical or family settings, they illustrate why problematic authority should be examined within the broader environments that may enable, tolerate, or reinforce harmful behavior.
Organizational conditions may influence whether intimidating or coercive practices are challenged, tolerated, or reinforced. For example, a workplace might overlook a supervisor's intimidation because the individual consistently meets performance targets, while an organization may discourage complaints out of concern for its reputation. In other settings, unquestioning obedience may be mistaken for loyalty, and employees may learn that disagreement carries professional consequences. These examples represent possible organizational patterns rather than conclusions that apply universally. They nevertheless demonstrate why personality-based explanations alone are insufficient. Organizational norms, performance incentives, leadership expectations, oversight procedures, and opportunities for safe disagreement may all contribute to understanding how harmful uses of authority develop or persist.
Authority and accountability are closely related, yet the effectiveness of accountability depends partly on how power and responsibility are distributed. Individuals entrusted with authority are often expected to make decisions, establish expectations, and evaluate the conduct of others. However, difficulties may arise when those same individuals exercise substantial influence over whether their own decisions can be questioned or reviewed. In such circumstances, accountability may become uneven, particularly when people affected by an authority figure's actions depend on that person's approval, resources, or continued support.
Research on governance and power relationships provides a conceptual framework for understanding these challenges. Eckersley et al. (2025) examined how power relationships influence accountability within public governance networks, distinguishing among three governance paradigms: traditional public administration, new public management, and new public governance. Their analysis identifies vertical, multidirectional, and horizontal accountability relationships, illustrating how different distributions of power and responsibility shape the mechanisms through which individuals and organizations are held accountable. Although this research concerns public governance rather than clinical psychology or abusive personality characteristics, it provides a useful perspective on how institutional structures, decision-making authority, and accountability mechanisms may influence the exercise of power.
These considerations have broader implications for leadership and organizational responsibility. Individuals who possess considerable authority may face limited opportunities for correction when others fear retaliation, depend on their decisions, or lack access to independent review. This does not mean that powerful individuals will necessarily misuse their positions, but it highlights why effective accountability cannot depend entirely on an authority figure's willingness to evaluate their own conduct. Consistent standards, transparent decision-making, accessible reporting procedures, independent oversight, and safeguards against retaliation may help ensure that authority remains subject to legitimate evaluation. Accountability should not be confused with automatic punishment; its purpose is to establish that decisions and conduct can be examined fairly and that responsibility applies across levels of authority.
A particularly important inconsistency emerges when leaders demand accountability from others while rejecting it for themselves. Authority becomes increasingly difficult to evaluate when the person exercising power also determines whether their conduct may be questioned. Responsible leadership therefore requires more than establishing expectations for those under one's authority. It also involves accepting appropriate scrutiny, acknowledging mistakes, and recognizing that the legitimacy of authority is strengthened rather than diminished when its exercise remains open to meaningful evaluation.
The sheepdog metaphor raises an important psychological question about whether an individual can become so closely identified with the role of protector that preserving authority gradually takes precedence over the responsibility to protect others. Although the research reviewed throughout this article does not establish a universal progression from protective identity to aggression, it identifies several psychological processes that may become relevant under particular circumstances. Overconfidence, threatened self-image, psychological entitlement, moral disengagement, defensive responses to criticism, and limitations in organizational accountability may each influence how authority is understood and exercised. These processes do not necessarily occur together, nor do they establish that individuals who identify as protectors are inherently more likely to engage in harmful behavior.
One possible pattern begins when an individual assumes a legitimate position of responsibility and gradually becomes increasingly invested in being perceived as indispensable, competent, or unquestionably correct. As personal identity becomes more closely connected to maintaining authority, disagreement may begin to feel threatening rather than constructive. Efforts to preserve control may intensify, and decisions that restrict, intimidate, or harm others may be rationalized as necessary for maintaining order, ensuring safety, or serving a greater good. This sequence represents an illustrative psychological possibility rather than an empirically validated causal model or diagnostic framework. Other pathways may involve deliberate exploitation, rigid beliefs about obedience, or organizational environments that tolerate or reward coercive practices. Equally important, many individuals exercise considerable authority throughout their lives without developing these patterns.
Rather than attempting to determine whether someone fits the symbolic category of sheepdog or wolf, a more meaningful evaluation considers whether the person's behavior remains consistent with the responsibilities they claim to uphold. Responsible authority allows room for reasonable disagreement, applies expectations proportionately, acknowledges mistakes, and remains open to appropriate scrutiny. By contrast, authority becomes concerning when criticism is consistently met with retaliation, restrictions exceed legitimate needs, or preserving obedience takes precedence over the dignity and appropriate autonomy of others. Although these observations cannot establish an individual's internal motivations with certainty, they direct attention toward observable behavior, interpersonal consequences, and accountability rather than assumptions about personality or identity.
Ultimately, the distinction between protection and domination is not determined solely by the authority figure's stated intentions or personal understanding of their role. It also requires examining how power is exercised, whether decisions remain proportionate to legitimate responsibilities, and whether the individuals affected retain appropriate opportunities for autonomy, dignity, and meaningful recourse. A person may sincerely believe they are acting protectively while engaging in behavior that warrants criticism or correction. Recognizing this possibility does not diminish the importance of legitimate authority; instead, it reinforces the responsibility to ensure that authority remains directed toward the purposes it is intended to serve.
Grossman and Christensen's (2004) analogy of sheep, wolves, and sheepdogs offers a memorable framework for considering protection, vulnerability, and aggression. Human behavior, however, cannot be adequately understood through fixed moral categories. Individuals may demonstrate courage, compassion, and responsible leadership in one circumstance while responding defensively or exercising poor judgment in another. Similarly, someone may repeatedly engage in intimidating or restrictive behavior while interpreting those actions as necessary expressions of responsibility or protection. The presence of a protective identity does not guarantee protective behavior, just as holding a position of authority does not inherently make someone aggressive or abusive.
The psychological research examined throughout this article suggests that understanding harmful uses of authority requires attention to the interaction of individual characteristics, situational pressures, interpersonal dynamics, and organizational conditions. Threatened self-image, overconfidence, entitlement, moral justification, and limitations in accountability may contribute to certain patterns of problematic behavior, although none provides a complete or universally applicable explanation. More importantly, these concepts highlight the need to evaluate authority according to how it is exercised rather than relying exclusively on the intentions, status, or self-perceptions of the individual who possesses it.
The central concern is not that individuals possess an ego, value their competence, or seek reasonable control over their circumstances. These experiences are common aspects of human functioning and may serve adaptive purposes. Difficulties arise when maintaining personal status, certainty, or authority becomes more important than fulfilling legitimate responsibilities and respecting the dignity and well-being of others. Responsible leadership and protection require the ability to make difficult decisions, establish appropriate boundaries, and respond to genuine threats, but they also require humility, proportionate judgment, and a willingness to remain accountable.
Ultimately, protection is defined not merely by the willingness or ability to exercise power, but by the responsibility with which that power is used. The most meaningful test of protective authority may be whether an individual remains willing to question their own decisions, acknowledge their limitations, and ensure that the power entrusted to them continues to serve the people it was intended to protect.
Experiences involving excessive interpersonal control, intimidation, or difficult power dynamics can have meaningful consequences for emotional well-being, personal confidence, and relationships. Individuals exposed to these experiences may struggle with anxiety, uncertainty, self-doubt, or difficulty establishing and maintaining healthy boundaries. Understanding how these interpersonal patterns develop, and recognizing the difference between appropriate authority and coercive behavior, can be an important part of making sense of difficult experiences and identifying healthier ways of responding.
The psychological concepts discussed in this article are drawn from several forms of scholarly literature, including experimental investigations, theoretical reviews, cross-sectional studies, action research, and organizational research. Each contributes a different perspective on human behavior, authority, and interpersonal relationships, while also carrying methodological limitations that influence how its findings should be interpreted. Research examining threatened egotism, power, narcissistic traits, psychological entitlement, empathy, and moral disengagement provides valuable insight into processes that may contribute to harmful or excessive uses of authority. However, these findings do not establish a single causal pathway through which protective identity develops into aggression, coercion, or abuse, nor do they demonstrate that individuals who identify strongly with protective roles are inherently more likely to engage in such behavior.
The concept of a protector becoming an aggressor should therefore be understood as an evidence-informed psychological interpretation rather than an established syndrome, diagnostic classification, or scientifically validated predictive model. Human behavior emerges within complex interactions among individual characteristics, interpersonal relationships, situational pressures, and broader social or organizational conditions. Consequently, evaluating potentially harmful uses of authority requires careful consideration of observable behavior, the proportionality and consequences of decisions, the experiences of those affected, and the availability of meaningful accountability. Psychological theories can help illuminate these dynamics, but they should not be used independently to assign diagnoses, determine an individual's motives, or make definitive judgments about another person's character.
Steven Loader, PhD, CMHC, is a licensed clinical mental health counselor and founder of A Sound Mind Counseling, a Utah-based private counseling practice specializing in anxiety, trauma, and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) therapy. He provides virtual mental health counseling services to adolescents ages 13–17 and adults throughout Utah, with an emphasis on evidence-informed treatment approaches and individualized clinical care.
Through his professional writing, Dr. Loader explores psychological research and its relevance to emotional well-being, interpersonal relationships, personality, and human behavior. His educational articles seek to make complex psychological concepts accessible to general readers while maintaining appropriate distinctions between scientific evidence, theoretical interpretation, and clinical application.
This article is intended for educational and informational purposes and should not be interpreted as a psychological assessment, clinical diagnosis, or substitute for individualized mental health care. The concepts discussed are presented to promote understanding of psychological processes associated with authority, interpersonal control, and potentially harmful behavior. They are not intended to establish that any particular individual is abusive, possesses a personality disorder, or is likely to engage in aggression.
Psychological characteristics and interpersonal behaviors should be evaluated within their specific circumstances by appropriately qualified professionals when clinical assessment is warranted. Readers experiencing emotional distress or difficulties related to controlling or intimidating relationships may benefit from seeking support from a licensed mental health professional. If you are in immediate danger, contact emergency services or an appropriate local crisis resource.
Experiences involving excessive control, intimidation, or unhealthy relationship dynamics can contribute to anxiety, emotional distress, and difficulty establishing healthy boundaries.
At A Sound Mind Counseling, Steven Loader, PhD, CMHC, provides virtual counseling to adults throughout Utah, specializing in anxiety, trauma, and EMDR therapy.
If you are seeking professional support, you can learn more about available counseling services or request an initial consultation.
Bandura, A. (1999). Moral disengagement in the perpetration of inhumanities. Personality and
Social Psychology Review, 3(3), 193–209. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327957pspr0303_3
Baumeister, R. F., Smart, L., & Boden, J. M. (1996). Relation of threatened egotism to violence
and aggression: The dark side of high self-esteem. Psychological Review, 103(1), 5–33.
https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.103.1.5
Baumeister, R. F., Bushman, B. J., & Campbell, W. K. (2000). Self-esteem, narcissism, and
aggression: Does violence result from low self-esteem or from threatened egotism?
Current Directions in Psychological Science, 9(1), 26–29.
https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8721.00053
Bushman, B. J., & Baumeister, R. F. (1998). Threatened egotism, narcissism, self-esteem, and
direct and displaced aggression: Does self-love or self-hate lead to violence? Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 219–229.
https://doi.org/10.1037/0022- 3514.75.1.219
Eckersley, P., Lakoma, K., Murphy, P., Caygill, T., & Pell, C. (2025). Accountability as a
function of power relationships in public governance networks. Public Administration,
103, 906–922. https://doi.org/10.1111/padm.13032
Fast, N. J., Sivanathan, N., Mayer, N. D., & Galinsky, A. D. (2012). Power and overconfident
decision-making. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 117(2), 249
260. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.obhdp.2011.11.009
Grossman, D., & Christensen, L. W. (2004). On combat: The psychology and physiology of
deadly conflict in war and peace. PPCT Research Publications.
Guo, L., & Yun, X. (2026). The impact of power on implicit attitudes toward violence: Empathy
as a mediator and moderator. BMC Psychology, 14, Article 889.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-026-04649-5
Keltner, D., Gruenfeld, D. H., & Anderson, C. (2003). Power, approach, and inhibition.
Psychological Review, 110(2), 265–284. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.110.2.265
Lundqvist, C., Camps, J., Vertommen, T., Barker-Ruchti, N., & Kolbeinsson, Ö. (2026). Toxic
leadership in high-performance sports and its consequences for mental health and
performance: A scoping review. International Review of Sport and Exercise
Psychology,19(2), 381–407. https://doi.org/10.1080/1750984X.2025.2457038
Queiri, A., & Alhejji, H. (2025). Examining the link between narcissism and perceived inequity:
The mediating role of sense of entitlement. International Journal of Organizational
Analysis, 33(10), 3747–3764. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJOA-07-2024-4654
Razer, M. (2021). From power struggle to benevolent authority and empathic limit-setting:
Creating inclusive school practice with excluded students through action research. Action
Research, 19(1), 9–36. https://doi.org/10.1177/1476750318776730